HomeBlogsMister Tim's blogFold Me some BEN!!!

Mister Tim's picture

 I don't know Ben Folds.  The guy won't even return my phone calls!  Hey!  I'm a stalker?

No.  What I mean is, I don't know Ben Folds.  I don't pretend to possess any kind of comprehensive knowledge about pop music and all the infinite personalities that emerge from the mostly-monochromatic musical landscape.  Ben Folds, so I have read in all the recent articles about his University A Cappella album, had his first big hit in 1997.  I was on a religious mission in Taiwan from 1996-1998 and extremely out of the pop culture picture (to this day I have not heard the real version of 'Wonderwall' - but I did hear Charlie play it on Lost!).  It was years later that I started hearing about him, and I've never searched out his music to partake of his Foldiness!

I have been singing 'Fred Jones pt. 2' with my group the Plumbers of Rome (at someone else's suggestion) for a few years.  I saw part of a Ben Folds live concert dvd at a friend's house a few years ago.  I hear people talk about him.  That's the extent of my Ben Folds knowledge!  (exclamation points added in honor of the title UNIVERSITY A CAPPELLA!)

Seriously, for years I wondered where the surname 'Foldsfive' came from (Irish?  German?).  You know, because I thought his name was 'Ben Foldsfive.'  

Like I said, I don't know him.

Why does this matter?

I finally got to the hear THE A CAPPELLA EVENT ALBUM OF THE DECADE (copyright 2009 New York Times, Boston Globe, etc).  I listened to it for free!  Online!  Legally!  Here: http://music.aol.com/new-releases-full-cds/#/2

Know my perspective: I don't know the songs, I don't know Ben Folds as an artist.  I don't particularly care for college a cappella in general.  I find the collegiate standard background syllables silly (at best) or lame (at worst).  I'm irritated by the egos that go along with college a cappella.  I'm frequently just BORED by the uninspired attempts at music.  I don't listen to recorded college a cappella, almost as a rule.  I can tolerate live performance, when the energy often makes for inspired presentations and can be quite enjoyable.  Most college a cappella recordings are redundant, un-inspired novelty versions of songs that will sound far, far better if I just go listen to the original recording.

So here's my reaction to "University A Cappella!" by Ben Folds, et. al:

Meh.

I was pretty bored, mostly.  I'm hearing most of these songs for the first time; don't have anything invested in them, so I was judging the songs as my first exposure to them.  Most of the performances were blah, most of the singing was just okay, the tuning and arrangement skill seemed front-loaded, getting progressively more blah as the album went along.  Many of the soloists were good, a lot of the singing was good, but _just_ good.  The basses had that choral-trying-to-sing-pop sound.  Vocal percussion was decent but mon-aural.  Jen jen joe joe no no nm nm zhen zhaou WHO CARES.

Seems like this Ben Folds character is quite a songwriter.  I love the variety of songs he writes, the whimsy and irreverance he plays with in lyrical forms and topical exploration.  The source material seems competent.  But I can't be sure because I'm not familiar with the originals.

I _DID_ really enjoy Mr. Folds' two versions of his own songs.  _Those_ were pretty cool.  He's not tied into the college a cappella convention, so he did some very interesting, unique things.  I loved the _energy_ of his tracks.  The playfulness.  The direct, un-weighted way he got to the core of the songs.  Dynamics!

These two tracks are good music, above and beyond the novelty of being a cappella.  They're interesting.  He uses vocal sounds the way he uses (I assume) instrumental sounds.  Energy, drive, precision.

He's not afraid to use choral sounds.  Most a cappella groups don't want to be seen as choirs, so they do the jen joe bum business.  

I would listen to those two tracks again.

The rest of the album, not so much.

Comments

I agree

I agree, Tim. This CD is really hard to listen to. The only exception for me is Sacramento State Jazz. That track was tight. Cool arrangement too. I also liked Effington, one of the two Ben Folds tracks. That one was fun and again had a cool arrangement.

If he was going for a raw, imperfect sound then he definitely achieved it. People definitely aren't getting to hear the best of college a cappella which I heard at the ICCA National's show.

No such thing as bad press? I don't know about that. People tend to think in general terms. I'm afraid "the masses" may get a false impression of college a cappella and a cappella in general. I wish he had done this CD with either better college groups or with pro groups. That would have been a lot better IMHO.

 

Comment viewing options

A Cappella Music - The Contemporary A Cappella Society web site is currently in planned maintenance. During this time it is not possible to add or edit content. Thank you for your patience.
Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
A Cappella Music - The Contemporary A Cappella Society web site is currently in planned maintenance. During this time it is not possible to add or edit content. Thank you for your patience.